Confidence Theater at Work: Nearly Half of Employees Feel Like Impostors

Confidence has become a workplace requirement. Employees are expected to sound certain in meetings, project expertise on Slack, and present themselves as capable and composed, even when they are still learning, adjusting, or struggling.

But behind that polished exterior, many workers feel like they are performing. New national survey data from MyPerfectResume shows that nearly half of U.S. employees experience impostor syndrome at work, while a much larger share feel ongoing pressure to appear more confident or knowledgeable than they actually are. 

The result is a growing gap between how workers feel internally and how they believe they must present themselves professionally, a phenomenon that can be described as confidence theater. This disconnect isn’t just uncomfortable. It has real consequences for career growth, visibility, and long-term confidence at work.

Key Findings

Nearly Half of Workers Feel Like Impostors

According to the survey, 43% of workers say they experience impostor feelings at work, a sense that their success is undeserved or that they will eventually be “found out,” despite their qualifications or performance.

At the same time, two-thirds of employees say they feel pressure to appear more confident or knowledgeable than they actually are. 

This environment encourages employees to manage impressions rather than openly ask questions, admit uncertainty, or take learning risks. Over time, that pressure can amplify self-doubt, especially in fast-paced roles or workplaces where success is highly visible and comparisons are constant.

Self-Doubt Is Driven by Workplace Conditions, Not Personal Ability

When asked what fuels their self-doubt, workers overwhelmingly point to structural and cultural pressures, not a lack of skill or competence. Nearly three-quarters of employees cite pressure or comparison as a driver of self-doubt, including:

• Comparing themselves to high-achieving peers (26%)
• Personal perfectionism (26%)
• High expectations from management (22%)

Additional contributors to feeling like a fraud at work include:

• Lack of feedback or recognition (24%)
• Rapidly changing technology or job demands (17%)

Only 25% of workers say they don’t experience self-doubt at work, reinforcing how widespread these pressures have become.

Rather than being a personal flaw, signs of imposter syndrome often emerge in environments where expectations are high, feedback is limited, and confidence is treated as a baseline requirement rather than a skill that develops over time.

How Impostor Syndrome Shows Up on the Job

Self-doubt rarely leads employees to completely disengage. Instead, it changes how they behave at work, often in ways that increase stress or reduce visibility.

The most common responses include:

• Overworking or minimizing themselves (56%), such as working extra hours, fixating on perfection, or downplaying achievements
• Internal doubt and constant comparison (45%), including second-guessing decisions or replaying mistakes
• Pulling back or becoming less visible (33%), avoiding new responsibilities, or staying quiet in meetings
• Seeking reassurance from colleagues or managers (19%)

While some of these behaviors may appear dedicated or cautious on the surface, they can quietly stall growth over time, especially when employees avoid visibility or opportunities out of fear of exposure.

The Career Impact Is Real and Measurable

Impostor syndrome doesn’t stay contained as a feeling. It directly affects career trajectories.

• 58% of workers say self-doubt or impostor feelings have negatively affected their career growth
• 7% say they have turned down major career opportunities as a result

These findings highlight a hidden cost of confidence theater: capable employees may opt out of promotions, stretch assignments, or leadership opportunities, not because they aren’t qualified, but because they don’t feel ready to perform at a higher level.

Leadership Silence Keeps the Cycle Going

One of the strongest patterns in the data is the rarity with which leaders model vulnerability.

• 65% of workers say leaders rarely or never talk openly about their own doubts or mistakes
• Only 35% say leaders discuss these topics even occasionally

When leaders present confidence as effortless and unbroken, it reinforces the idea that uncertainty is a weakness to hide. Employees learn quickly that confidence is expected, while doubt is private, if it’s acknowledged at all.

This silence can unintentionally normalize impostor feelings, leading employees to believe they are the only ones struggling.

Why Confidence Theater Persists

Confidence theater thrives in workplaces that prioritize performance signals over learning signals. Titles, visibility, speed, and certainty are rewarded, while curiosity, experimentation, and questions are often undervalued.

In these environments, employees don’t stop doubting themselves; they just get better at hiding it. Over time, that performance gap can erode trust, increase burnout, and limit growth across teams, especially for early-career workers, career changers, and those in rapidly evolving roles.

Together, these findings suggest that impostor syndrome isn’t just an internal struggle. It’s closely tied to how workplaces reward confidence, certainty, and visibility, often without leaving room for learning, doubt, or growth in public.

Methodology

The findings presented in this report are based on a nationally representative survey conducted by MyPerfectResume using Pollfish in December 2025. The survey collected responses from 1,000 U.S. adults currently employed full-time. Respondents answered a mix of single-selection and multiple-choice questions about impostor syndrome, self-doubt, workplace culture, leadership behavior, and career confidence.

Demographic Breakdown

The survey sample consisted of 56% female and 44% male respondents. Age distribution included 25% aged 65 or older, 53% aged 35–64, and 22% aged 18–34. Regarding education, 61% reported having at least some college education, while 40% had a high school diploma or less.

About MyPerfectResume

MyPerfectResume Resume Builder with professional templates is designed to help job seekers elevate their careers. The easy-to-use platform was created to eliminate the hassle of resume writing, offering professionally written examples, free expert tips, step-by-step guidance to make a resume, and valuable interview advice to create an outstanding job application effortlessly. Since 2012, MyPerfectResume’s Resume Builder has helped more than 11 million job seekers create their perfect resumes online. Its comprehensive employment surveys have been featured in Forbes, Yahoo! Finance, CNBC, Newsweek, USA Today, BBC, Workable, and more. Stay connected with MyPerfectResume’s latest Facebook, LinkedIn, Instagram, X, and Pinterest updates.